Maine Tenant-Landlord Arbitration: Your Rights and Options

Facing disputes with your landlord—such as issues with repairs, evictions, or rent increases—can feel overwhelming. In Maine, renters have several options for resolving these disagreements formally, including arbitration. Understanding how tenant-landlord arbitration programs work in Maine can help you seek a fair resolution without immediately turning to costly court proceedings.

What Is Tenant-Landlord Arbitration?

Arbitration is a process where both the tenant and landlord agree to let a neutral third party (the arbitrator) hear their case and make a decision. It is typically faster and less formal than going to court, and the arbitrator’s decision can be binding or non-binding, depending on your agreement.

Does Maine Offer Official Tenant-Landlord Arbitration?

Unlike some states, Maine does not have a statewide, government-run residential arbitration board. Most landlord-tenant disputes are managed by the Maine District Court system. However, Maine courts and legal aid organizations frequently encourage mediation and voluntary arbitration outside of court, especially for disputes regarding:

• Security deposit returns
• Maintenance or repair issues
• Eviction or lease disputes
• Alleged lease violations

Local dispute resolution programs and some city housing authorities may offer or suggest non-court arbitration or mediation. You can also access dispute resolution services through organizations such as the Maine Judicial Branch Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) services.

How Can Maine Renters Start Arbitration or Mediation?

While arbitration is not required by law, both parties (you and your landlord) must agree to participate. If you wish to resolve a dispute through arbitration or mediation, follow these general steps:

• Talk to your landlord and suggest mediation or arbitration for your disagreement.
• Contact a local ADR provider, such as a Community Mediation Center, or seek a referral from the court or a legal aid group.
• If both parties agree, complete any necessary forms (see below) and schedule the session.

Key Official Forms and How to Use Them

• Request for Mediation/ADR in Maine District Court (No official form number – varies by court): Use this when your case is already in court, for example, if your landlord has filed for eviction and you want to request that the court orders mediation before the actual trial. Find forms and information through the Maine Judicial Branch Forms Library by searching for "mediation" or requesting at your local courthouse.
• Complaint for Forcible Entry and Detainer (Eviction) (Form CV-007): Filed by landlords to start an eviction. Tenants who receive this should consider mediation before or during the eviction process. See the official form at the Maine Eviction Complaint Form (CV-007).

Always check with your local court for the right form. If included as part of a court case, mediation can sometimes help both parties reach a solution without needing a judge’s ruling.

Who Handles Rental Disputes in Maine?

The official body overseeing residential tenancies—including mediation, arbitration, and court proceedings—is the Maine Judicial Branch District Court. This court manages landlord-tenant cases under Maine's governing legislation, the Maine Revised Statutes: Title 14, Chapter 709 - Forcible Entry and Detainer.¹

Your Rights as a Renter in Arbitration and Dispute Resolution

It's important to know:

• You must agree to participate in mediation or arbitration—your landlord cannot force you unless required by court order, which is rare in Maine.
• You can bring evidence, witnesses, and even an advocate (like an attorney or housing counselor) to an arbitration session.
• The outcome may be binding or not, depending on your agreement with the landlord before arbitration begins.

What If Mediation or Arbitration Fails?

If you cannot resolve the dispute through these programs, your case may proceed to the District Court for a formal hearing. You retain all your rights as a renter throughout the court process under Maine law.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I use arbitration if my landlord files for eviction against me?
   Arbitration is not automatically provided, but you and your landlord can agree to use mediation or arbitration at any point. You may also request court-ordered mediation when responding to an eviction.
2. Do I have to pay for arbitration or mediation?
   Community mediation is often free or low-cost in Maine, but private arbitration may come with fees. Check with local providers or the court for specifics.
3. Is an arbitrator’s decision binding in Maine?
   Only if you and your landlord agree, in writing, beforehand. Most mediations result in voluntary agreements rather than binding decisions.
4. Where can I find official tenant-landlord forms?
   You can find key forms on the Maine Judicial Branch Forms Library. For mediation, consult your local courthouse or the Alternative Dispute Resolution Services page.
5. Can I bring someone to arbitration or mediation for support?
   Yes. You can bring an advocate, legal aid attorney, or trusted person to help you during your session.

Conclusion: What Maine Renters Should Know

• Maine does not have a formal statewide arbitration board for landlord-tenant disputes, but mediation and arbitration can be arranged voluntarily or through court referral.
• The Maine District Court and local ADR services can help resolve disputes regarding eviction, repairs, or lease disagreements.
• Always consult Maine's rental laws and official court resources for up-to-date rights and guidance.

Knowing your options—mediation or court—puts you in a stronger position to solve issues fairly and respectfully.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Maine Judicial Branch Forms Library: Access all landlord-tenant court forms and ADR information.
• Pine Tree Legal Assistance: Free legal help for Maine renters.
• Maine Attorney General’s Consumer Housing Division: Advice and mediation resources for both landlords and tenants.
• Maine Judicial Branch Alternative Dispute Resolution Services: Information on mediation and arbitration programs in Maine courts.

---

1. Maine Revised Statutes: Title 14, Chapter 709 – Forcible Entry and Detainer (Landlord-Tenant Law).
2. Maine Judicial Branch - District Court: Landlord-Tenant Cases.
3. Maine Judicial Branch Alternative Dispute Resolution Services.
4. Maine Attorney General's Housing Mediation Programs.

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations