When You Can Legally Refuse to Move In After Inspection in South Dakota

Preparing to move into a new rental should be an exciting step, but it’s important to make sure the property meets legal and safety standards. In South Dakota, renters have specific rights if an inspection reveals issues just before move-in. This guide will clarify when you can lawfully refuse to move in, what forms and steps are involved, and how to protect yourself and your deposit.

South Dakota Rental Inspections: What Should You Expect?

Landlords in South Dakota must provide a safe and habitable rental property at move-in. While there is no statewide law requiring a formal pre-move-in inspection, renters are highly encouraged to perform their own inspection before accepting the keys.

You should look for:

• Working smoke detectors and safety features
• No major damage, leaks, or mold
• Functioning plumbing and electricity
• Clean conditions and reasonable repair of appliances

What If the Rental Doesn’t Meet Basic Standards?

If the unit is unsafe or significantly different from what was promised, you may have the right to refuse to move in. According to the South Dakota Landlord and Tenant Act, landlords must deliver possession of the premises and maintain them in a fit and habitable condition^[1].

When Can You Refuse to Move In?

You may legally refuse to move in if:

• The property is not habitable (for example, if it has no running water or is infested)
• Required health or safety repairs are not completed as promised in writing
• The landlord fails to provide agreed-upon equipment or major features (such as heating or appliances)
• Serious undisclosed issues come to light during your inspection

However, you cannot usually refuse to move in for minor wear-and-tear, cosmetic flaws, or issues that do not make the property unsafe or uninhabitable.

Official Required Disclosures

South Dakota law requires landlords to disclose certain details if the property was used for manufacturing methamphetamines or if the unit is subject to legal orders or code violations. If these aren’t disclosed, you may have grounds to cancel or refuse the lease^[2]. You can read about South Dakota's landlord-tenant disclosure requirements through the Department of Revenue website.

Forms to Use: Refusing Possession or Notifying the Landlord

South Dakota doesn’t provide a specific statewide form for refusing to move in. Instead, renters should use a written notice (a simple letter or email) clearly stating why you will not accept the property. Keep copies for your records.

• Example: If an inspection reveals a broken furnace in January, email your landlord that you cannot move in until repairs are complete. Request confirmation and a timeline.

For issues involving unreturned deposits after refusing possession, you may use:

• Security Deposit Demand Letter - While not a government form, you may request the return of your deposit in writing if you do not move in. A sample template is available on the South Dakota Attorney General's website under Landlord Tenant Rights.

Who Handles Rental Disputes in South Dakota?

In South Dakota, the official forum for residential rental disputes is your local County Small Claims Court. There is no state-level tribunal or board. Renters may also contact the South Dakota Attorney General’s Office – Consumer Protection Division for guidance.

Summary of Refusal Process & Action Steps

If your inspection shows the property is not safe or habitable, you:

• Notify your landlord in writing of the problems and your intention not to move in
• Request that repairs or disclosures be made before you accept keys
• If unresolved, consider requesting your deposit back, and keep documentation
• If a dispute arises, you may file in Small Claims Court

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I get my security deposit back if I refuse to move in?
   Yes, if you have legitimate grounds for refusal (like safety violations), you may be entitled to your deposit's return. Always request it in writing and document why you refused to move in.
2. Is the landlord required to fix every problem before move-in?
   No, but the landlord must ensure the property is safe, habitable, and compliant with all required disclosures. Minor cosmetic issues may not require immediate repair.
3. What if my landlord disagrees with my refusal?
   You can try mediation, or take the issue to Small Claims Court. Provide your written notice, inspection evidence, and a summary of communications.
4. Where can I report a landlord for not making the property habitable?
   You may contact your county's Small Claims Court or the South Dakota Attorney General’s Office – Consumer Protection Division.
5. Is there an official inspection form for South Dakota rentals?
   No, there is not a mandated statewide checklist. Renters are encouraged to make a detailed notes and photographs during their own inspection for documentation.

Key Takeaways for South Dakota Renters

• You can refuse to move in if the rental is unsafe, uninhabitable, or important disclosures are missing.
• Use written notice and keep documentation to protect your rights.
• Disputes may be handled by Small Claims Court or through state consumer protection services.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• South Dakota Attorney General’s Office – Landlord/Tenant Rights: Guidance and sample letters
• County Small Claims Court Directory: Where to file rental disputes
• SD Department of Revenue: Rental Property Disclosures

---

1. South Dakota Landlord and Tenant Act – Title 43, Chapter 32
2. SD Department of Revenue – Landlord Obligations and Disclosures

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations