Sub-Metering and Master Meter: Renters’ Utility Rights in NY

Understanding how utilities are billed is essential for renters in New York. With buildings moving toward sub-metering, tenants often have questions about their rights, protections, and responsibilities. Here's what New York renters need to know about sub-metering and master meter utility billing, and how to protect themselves.

Understanding Utility Billing: Master Meter vs. Sub-Metering

Master Meter means the building has one main utility meter. The landlord receives the total bill and allocates costs among tenants, often as a flat rate or blended rent. Sub-metering means each individual apartment gets a separate meter, with tenants billed directly for their own usage.

• Master Meter: Landlord controls billing. Utilities may be included in the rent or itemized.
• Sub-metering: Each tenant is billed for their own electrical (or other utility) usage.

For tenants, the main differences involve billing transparency, dispute resolution, and protection from overcharges or unfair shut-offs.

What Are My Rights with Sub-Metering in New York?

Sub-metering of electricity is closely regulated by the New York State Public Service Commission (PSC). Landlords cannot simply switch to sub-metering without following rules designed to protect renters. State law requires:

• Written notice to all affected tenants before sub-metering starts
• PSC approval of the landlord’s sub-metering plan
• Renters must be informed of rates, billing procedures, and dispute rights
• Protections against arbitrary utility shutoff
• Tenant rights to challenge bills and address complaints with the PSC

Where to Find the Laws

Your rights are protected by several sources:

• New York State Real Property Law^[1]
• Public Service Law & Rules for utility billing rules
• PSC regulations, especially guidance for sub-metering in rentals

Master-metered tenants may have fewer protections regarding individual usage, but are still covered by state landlord–tenant law regarding fair charges and habitability.

Notice, Billing, and Dispute Process

When a landlord wants to introduce or change sub-metering:

• Tenants must get written notice outlining the change, PSC plan, and proposed rates.
• Renters have the right to participate in the PSC process if they object.

Monthly sub-metered utility bills should clearly list charges, usage, and any late fees. If you disagree with a charge, the PSC provides a complaint process for renters.

Filing a Utility Complaint or Dispute

If communication with your landlord does not resolve a billing error or dispute, you have the right to file a formal complaint with the PSC using their official form:

• PSC Complaint/Inquiry Form
  Submit a complaint online or download the Utility Complaint Form.
  Example: If you’re billed for electricity under sub-metering but believe you were overcharged or not given adequate notice, you can use this form to open a case with PSC.

The commission will investigate your complaint and issue a decision, giving you strong recourse if landlord billing does not meet state standards.

Evictions and Utility Shutoff Protections

It is illegal for a landlord to shut off essential utilities—like heat or water—to force you to pay rent or move out, even in master-metered buildings. Utility terminations follow strict PSC and local laws, including specific notice requirements.

• Report illegal shut-offs to the NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) or PSC
• Landlords who violate these laws may face civil penalties

Relevant Official Forms and Agencies

• PSC Utility Complaint/Inquiry Form (no form number)
  Use if you have an unresolved complaint or dispute with utility billing under sub-metering.
  Link: PSC complaints and form

The tribunal overseeing utility and rental housing issues is the New York City Housing Court for NYC or the local Housing Court/rent board in other areas. Utility disputes are handled primarily by the PSC.

FAQs for New York Renters on Metered Utilities

1. What should I do if my sub-metered utility bill seems incorrect?
   First, ask your landlord for itemization and explanation. If unresolved, file a complaint with the PSC complaint office.
2. Does my landlord have to warn me before switching to sub-metered utilities?
   Yes, landlords must provide advance written notice and outline your rights under state law.
3. Can my landlord shut off my utilities in a dispute?
   No. Shutting off essential services to force payment or eviction is illegal in New York under both housing and utility laws.
4. How can I find out what rules apply if I live outside NYC?
   Check your local housing court or rent board, and refer to PSC regulations covering all of New York State.
5. Is the sub-metering process different in rent-stabilized buildings?
   Special rules apply in rent-stabilized apartments; landlords must get regulatory approval and ensure tenants’ total rent-plus-utility charges comply with state limits.

Key Takeaways for NY Renters

• Tenants have strong protections when utilities are billed through sub-metering.
• Written notice and PSC approval are required for changes to utility billing methods.
• You can challenge unfair bills or shut-offs via official New York agencies.

Understanding these rights can help you handle disputes and know where to turn for help.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• New York State Public Service Commission (PSC): For utility billing and sub-metering concerns statewide
• New York State Homes and Community Renewal (HCR): Tenant protections and rent regulation info
• NYC Department of Housing Preservation & Development (HPD): Apartment complaints for NYC residents
• NYC Housing Court: Dispute resolution for city renters

---

1. ^[1] See New York State Real Property Law for tenant utility billing rights.
2. “Submetering Requirements – Multiple Dwellings,” PSC official policy.
3. Access PSC rules and complaint procedures here.
4. NYC Housing Court information via official court site.

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations