DIY Tenant Disputes or Hire a Lawyer in WV?

If you are a renter in West Virginia, you may face situations like late repairs, rent increases, or even eviction. Sometimes, these issues can be handled on your own (DIY), but other times, hiring an attorney is the smartest move. Understanding when to seek legal help is important to protect your rights under West Virginia's landlord-tenant law. This article walks you through how to make the right choice—and where to turn for help if you need it.

DIY: Handling Rental Disputes on Your Own

Many common problems can be resolved directly between you and your landlord, without a lawyer. Choosing the DIY approach can save you time and money, especially for straightforward issues.

Typical Situations You Can DIY

• Requesting Repairs: If your unit needs maintenance, send a written repair request to your landlord. Document everything.
• Security Deposit Returns: If you're moving out, you can request your security deposit back in writing under state timelines.
• Responding to Notices: Landlords must give proper notice for rent increases or entering your unit. You can reply in writing or seek clarification.

Try to keep all communication in writing (such as email or certified mail). This provides proof if the dispute escalates.

Official Forms for Renters

• Answer to Complaint (Form SCA-C-200): If you receive an eviction (unlawful detainer) complaint in Magistrate Court, use this form to respond. Fill it out and submit it to the clerk within 5 days of receiving the summons. Get the official form here.
• Request for Return of Security Deposit: While West Virginia doesn't have a specific statewide official form, you can write a simple letter requesting your deposit. Be sure to reference WV Code § 37-6A and send your request to your landlord's address from the lease.
• Complaint Form: If your landlord is violating the code (e.g., refusing repairs), you may file a complaint with your local city or county code enforcement or health department.

When to Consider Hiring a Lawyer

Certain rental situations are complex or high-stakes. An attorney's expertise can save you from costly mistakes and ensure your rights are fully protected.

Common Scenarios for Legal Help

• Facing Eviction: If you've been served an eviction notice or lawsuit, a lawyer can review your case, look for landlord mistakes, or negotiate a settlement.
• Discrimination or Retaliation: When you believe you're being evicted, harassed, or refused housing for illegal reasons (such as race, disability, or because you complained about unsafe conditions), legal aid can help file a complaint or lawsuit.
• Large Damages or Claims: If your landlord is suing you for large sums (e.g., for alleged damages) or withholding your deposit unlawfully, legal guidance may prevent costly errors.
• Multiple Court Documents: If you receive court papers and aren't sure how to respond, an attorney can clarify deadlines, help you file a response, and defend your rights.

West Virginia offers some legal aid to low-income renters facing eviction or landlord disputes (see resources below).

Who Handles Rental Disputes in West Virginia?

Rental disputes and evictions are typically heard by your local Magistrate Court. These courts take complaints involving residential leases, evictions (unlawful detainer actions), and landlord-tenant money claims. You can search for your county's Magistrate Court using this official court directory.

West Virginia Landlord-Tenant Legislation

• West Virginia Code Chapter 37, Article 6 (Residential Leases, Eviction, and Tenant Rights)
• West Virginia Code Chapter 37, Article 6A (Security Deposits)

These laws explain your rights as a renter and your landlord's obligations. You can reference the full legislation on the West Virginia Legislature official website.

Action Steps for Renters

• Start by communicating in writing with your landlord about any rental issue.
• If you receive legal paperwork, respond by the deadline—use the appropriate forms linked above.
• Gather documentation: Save copies of emails, repair requests, notices, and your lease.
• Contact legal aid if you feel overwhelmed, face eviction, or encounter discrimination.
• Check your local court or legal aid offices for in-person help if you need guidance completing forms.

FAQ: Renters' Legal Choices in West Virginia

1. Can I handle an eviction notice without a lawyer in West Virginia?
   Yes, you may respond to an eviction lawsuit (unlawful detainer) yourself. Use the Magistrate Court's "Answer to Complaint" form and attend your hearing. However, if you're unsure or feel the case is unfair, consult legal aid for advice.
2. How do I request the return of my security deposit in West Virginia?
   Send a written request to your landlord after moving out. Reference WV Code § 37-6A and provide your forwarding address. If the deposit is not returned within the required time, you may file a claim in Magistrate Court.
3. Is there free legal aid for renters facing eviction?
   Yes. Legal Aid of West Virginia offers free services for eligible renters. They can advise you, help fill out forms, or represent you in court if you qualify.
4. Do I need a lawyer for small repair or maintenance issues?
   Usually, no. First, report the issue to your landlord in writing. If unresolved, contact your local code enforcement. Persistent problems may require legal help, but it often resolves without a lawyer.
5. Which court handles rental disputes and evictions in West Virginia?
   Rental disputes and evictions are handled by your county's Magistrate Court.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Legal Aid of West Virginia – Housing Help: Free legal advice and representation for qualifying renters
• West Virginia Magistrate Courts: Handles residential evictions and disputes
• West Virginia Landlord-Tenant Laws: Full text of tenant and landlord legislation
• Local Magistrate Court Search: Find your county court’s contact info
• WV DHHR Housing Services: Rental assistance and housing support

---

1. "West Virginia Code Chapter 37, Article 6." Official state legislation
2. West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals. "Magistrate Court Forms." Official court forms page
3. Legal Aid of West Virginia. Housing Legal Resources
4. West Virginia Magistrate Court Directory. County court information

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations