Vermont Tenant Rights: Sub-Metering vs. Master Meter Utilities

If you rent a home or apartment in Vermont, you may wonder how your utility bills are calculated. Knowing whether your landlord uses sub-metering or a master meter can impact your monthly costs and your rights as a tenant. This guide explains the key differences, outlines your protections, and helps you resolve disputes fairly under Vermont law.

Understanding Utility Billing: Sub-Metering vs. Master Meter

Utilities like electricity, water, and heat are often a major part of rental living expenses. There are two common billing systems in Vermont rentals:

• Sub-Metering: Each rental unit has its own meter and tenants pay only for the utilities they personally use. Bills usually come in your name from the utility company, or through the landlord if they are authorized to resell.
• Master Meter: The landlord receives a single bill covering the whole building and divides utility costs among tenants using a formula—often by unit size or number of occupants.

While both systems are legal in Vermont, tenant rights differ depending on how utilities are billed.

Your Rights with Sub-Metered Utilities in Vermont

When your apartment is sub-metered:

• You are responsible only for your own consumption.
• Landlords cannot charge more per unit of energy or water than the public utility's rate.
• The utility service provider must offer you consumer protections like shut-off notice and dispute procedures.

If your landlord tries to resell utilities at an inflated rate, it's important to know this may violate Vermont's consumer protection rules.

Master Metering: What Vermont Renters Should Know

If you're in a building with a master meter:

• Utility costs may be bundled into the rent or billed separately by the landlord.
• The landlord must disclose in writing how costs are divided between units (usually in the lease).
• Tenants can request to see the building’s utility bills.
• If there is a system failure (like a central heating outage), the landlord is generally responsible for repairs and resulting damages.

Vermont’s Residential Rental Agreements Act protects your right to safe and reliable utility service, regardless of how it’s metered.^[1]

Changing Utility Responsibility: Notice & Lease Clauses

If utility billing changes during your tenancy (for example, if you must begin paying for heat that was previously included), Vermont law requires:

• Written notice of the change before it takes effect.
• An amendment or update to your lease or rental agreement.
• Disclosure of the estimated cost and method of allocation.

If you do not receive proper notice, you can contest the change through the Vermont Superior Court’s Civil Division, which hears landlord-tenant disputes.

Relevant Forms for Vermont Renters

• Small Claims Complaint (Form 800-00004): Used if you believe you have been overcharged for utilities and want to recover costs. You can file this form with your local Vermont Superior Court - Civil Division.
• Notice of Rent Withholding: While Vermont does not provide a standard form, tenants may withhold rent under certain circumstances, such as utility service not being provided as required by the lease. For guidance, see the Vermont Legal Help section on rent withholding.

Always use the most recent version of any form and submit it according to the instructions on the Vermont Judiciary website.^[2]

Resolving Disputes: Where to Get Help

If you can't reach an agreement with your landlord about utility charges, you may seek assistance from the Vermont Superior Court - Civil Division, which serves as Vermont's official tribunal for residential tenancy matters.^[3] You may file a complaint or small claims action as needed.

FAQ: Vermont Tenant Rights for Utility Billing

1. Can my landlord bill me more than the actual cost of utilities?
   No. Vermont law prohibits landlords from charging tenants more than the actual cost, or above the utility company’s set rates for sub-metered utilities.
2. Does my landlord have to disclose how utilities are divided?
   Yes, for master-metered systems, your landlord must provide written notice of the allocation method—usually as part of your lease.
3. What if I suspect my landlord is overcharging for utilities?
   Request a copy of the utility bill and a written explanation of the charges. If you believe the charges are not fair or legal, you can file a small claims complaint with the court.
4. Who handles complaints about utility shut-offs or disputes?
   Complaints can be addressed to the utility provider, and if not resolved, you can seek help from the Vermont Superior Court - Civil Division.
5. Can my landlord shut off utilities during a dispute?
   No, landlords cannot disconnect essential utilities as a means of eviction or retaliation under Vermont law.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways for Vermont Renters

• Landlords cannot profit from basic utility billing—they must charge actual costs or what the utility company charges.
• Always request and keep documentation of how your utility charges are calculated and paid.
• Vermont laws offer clear protections for utility fairness—use available forms and court resources for disputes.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Vermont Superior Court - Civil Division: Handles official landlord-tenant disputes and small claims actions.
• Vermont Legal Help – Housing: Practical advice and forms for renters, including issues regarding utility charges and rights.
• Vermont Department of Public Service: Utility regulation, complaint process, and consumer protections.

---

1. Vermont Statutes, Title 9, Chapter 137: Residential Rental Agreements Act
2. Vermont Judiciary: Civil Division Forms
3. Vermont Superior Court – Civil Division

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations