Disputing a Water Bill as a Tenant in South Carolina

If you’re renting a home or apartment in South Carolina and have discovered an unexpected or unusually high water bill, you’re not alone. Disputes over water bills can happen due to errors, leaks, or unclear lease agreements. It’s important to understand your rights, steps you can take to resolve the issue, and where you can turn for help under state law.

Who Is Responsible for the Water Bill?

The responsibility for paying water bills in South Carolina is typically outlined in your lease agreement. Landlords must state in writing whether utilities like water are included in the rent or billed separately. If your lease is unclear, ask your landlord for written clarification.

• Inclusive leases: Landlord pays water as part of rent.
• Separate utility billing: Tenant pays water directly to the provider or landlord based on use.

For most rental units, the South Carolina Residential Landlord and Tenant Act governs these arrangements and ensures that tenants’ rights are protected¹.

Common Causes of Water Bill Disputes

• Miscalculated usage or meter errors
• Undisclosed fees or extra charges
• Hidden leaks in the plumbing
• Responsibility confusion (e.g., repairs not made by landlord)

Knowing the likely cause can help you resolve a dispute more efficiently.

How to Dispute a Water Bill in South Carolina

Follow these steps if you believe your water bill is incorrect or unfair:

• Review your lease agreement. Check what it says about water billing and responsibility for repairs.
• Contact your landlord promptly in writing. Clearly outline your concern and request a review or explanation of the charges.
• Request meter readings or billing records. You have a right to see how your usage was measured and billed.
• Check for leaks. If you suspect a leak, report it immediately so repairs can be made.
• Contact your water utility. Ask about their dispute process, which usually involves requesting a re-read or investigation.

When to Use Official Forms and File a Complaint

If you are unable to resolve the dispute directly with your landlord or utility provider, you can take further action. South Carolina tenants can submit a complaint to the South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs if you believe you are being overcharged or subject to unfair billing practices. Their complaint form is:

• Consumer Complaint Form – Used when you believe a business (e.g., landlord) has engaged in unfair or deceptive practices related to utilities or billing.
  • When to use: If you’ve received an unexplained water bill and your landlord or property manager does not address your written concerns within a reasonable timeframe. Also appropriate if you believe there’s misrepresentation regarding who pays for water.
  • How to use: Complete the form with all details, attach your water bill and any relevant lease pages, and submit it by mail, fax, or online.
  • Official Consumer Complaint Form PDF

What Happens After Filing a Complaint?

The South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs will review your case and may contact your landlord or utility provider to investigate. They do not provide direct legal representation or force a resolution, but the process can encourage fair treatment and sometimes lead to corrective action.

Legal Protections for South Carolina Renters

South Carolina’s Residential Landlord and Tenant Act protects tenants against unreasonable charges and requires landlords to keep plumbing in good working order. If a landlord fails to repair leaks or improperly bills tenants, renters have rights to request repairs and accurate billing¹.

What Tribunal Handles Rental Disputes in South Carolina?

Rental disputes, including utility billing, are generally handled by the South Carolina Magistrate Court. If your issue cannot be resolved informally or through mediation, you may file a claim here for resolution, especially if the dispute may lead to eviction or a withheld security deposit.

Tips for Preventing Water Bill Disputes

• Request written clarification about utility responsibilities before signing a lease
• Perform a move-in inspection and document current meter readings
• Report maintenance issues, especially leaks, without delay
• Retain copies of all bills, payments, and correspondence

1. Can my landlord charge me for a water bill that was caused by a plumbing leak?
   Generally, if the leak was not caused by your negligence, your landlord is responsible for repairs and related excess charges¹. However, always check your lease and report leaks promptly.
2. Who do I contact first if I think my water bill is wrong?
   Start with your landlord and the water utility. If unresolved, you may contact the South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs for assistance.
3. Can my landlord shut off my water for nonpayment?
   No. Landlords cannot legally shut off water or other essential utilities to force payment or evict tenants. This is considered an illegal eviction practice under South Carolina law¹.
4. What documents should I keep when disputing a bill?
   Keep copies of your lease, all water bills, meter readings, photos of possible leaks, and all correspondence with your landlord or utility.
5. Can a water bill dispute be a reason for eviction?
   While nonpayment of rent or utilities can lead to eviction, you have a right to dispute bills you believe are inaccurate. Eviction must follow formal court processes, not summary utility shutoff or threats¹.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• South Carolina Department of Consumer Affairs – Utilities, landlord-tenant complaints, and consumer protection.
• South Carolina Magistrate Court – For unresolved disputes leading to court claims.
• SC LawHelp – Free or low-cost legal aid for tenants.
• South Carolina Residential Landlord and Tenant Act – Complete official text of the relevant tenancy law.

---

1. South Carolina Code § 27-40-410, § 27-40-510: Residential Landlord and Tenant Act

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations