Arbitration Options for Pennsylvania Renters and Landlords

If you rent a home or apartment in Pennsylvania and face a disagreement with your landlord, you may be wondering about the best, fastest way to resolve it. Whether you're dealing with rent increases, repairs, deposits, or eviction notices, Pennsylvania offers several dispute resolution options — including arbitration, mediation, and legal assistance — that help tenants and landlords settle matters outside of court. Here’s what every renter in Pennsylvania needs to know about these programs, the forms you might need, and your legal protections.

Understanding Tenant-Landlord Arbitration and Mediation in Pennsylvania

Unlike some other states, Pennsylvania does not have a single statewide tribunal handling all residential tenancy matters. Instead, most housing disagreements are managed in local Magisterial District Courts or through city-specific mediation programs. Many Pennsylvania cities — such as Philadelphia and Pittsburgh — offer arbitration and mediation services to help resolve issues like unpaid rent, habitability complaints, and lease disputes without going to a full trial.

What Is Arbitration and How Does It Differ from Mediation?

• Arbitration: A neutral third party (the arbitrator) hears both sides and makes a decision. While less formal than court, the decision can sometimes be binding.
• Mediation: A neutral mediator helps parties talk through their issues and reach a voluntary agreement, but doesn’t make a binding ruling.

For most renters, the process starts with mediation. Many city courts or housing agencies offer these services at no or low cost.

Local Dispute Resolution Programs for Renters

Your options depend on your location:

• Philadelphia: The Eviction Diversion Program helps tenants and landlords resolve disputes with mediation and housing counselors before eviction filings.
• Pittsburgh: The Pittsburgh Commission on Human Relations provides free mediation for housing disputes.
• Other Pennsylvania Locations: Many Magisterial District Courts offer information about voluntary mediation or may refer disputes to local programs.

Official Forms and How to Use Them

• Landlord-Tenant Complaint (AOPC 308-05):
  When to Use: If a dispute cannot be resolved through mediation or arbitration, your landlord may file this form to recover possession of property or request unpaid rent. Renters can use this form to countersue (e.g., for deposit return).
  Where to Find: Available from the Pennsylvania Courts official forms library (search “Landlord-Tenant Complaint”).
  Example: If your landlord files for eviction after failed mediation, you will receive this form as part of the court process. You may use it to respond or participate in a hearing.
• Request for Mediation (Philadelphia Eviction Diversion Program):
  When to Use: Philadelphia tenants facing eviction can request free mediation through this program prior to a formal eviction filing.
  Where to Find: Download the form from the Philadelphia Eviction Diversion Program portal.
  Example: If you receive an eviction notice, you can file this form to pause legal proceedings and request a mediation appointment.

Your Rights Under Pennsylvania Law

Pennsylvania's Landlord and Tenant Act of 1951 is the primary law protecting renters in residential housing. This legislation outlines your right to proper notice before eviction, fair handling of security deposits, and access to habitable housing^[1].

How the Arbitration and Mediation Process Works

• Step 1: Try to resolve the issue directly with your landlord in writing and keep copies of all records.
• Step 2: If unsuccessful, contact your local dispute resolution program or court for a mediation or arbitration referral. In Philadelphia, use the Eviction Diversion Program; elsewhere, ask your local Magisterial District Court clerk about available services.
• Step 3: Submit any required forms (see above).
• Step 4: Attend the mediation/arbitration session. Bring copies of your lease, payment records, letters, and related documentation.
• Step 5: If an agreement is reached, make sure you get it in writing. If not, the matter may proceed to the local Magisterial District Court.

This process offers renters and landlords a chance to settle disputes quickly and avoid the stress and cost of a formal court case.

Pennsylvania's Official Tribunal for Tenancy Disputes

Residential tenancy disputes in Pennsylvania are handled through the Magisterial District Courts. These courts hear cases about possession, rent owed, and property conditions. Their decisions follow the state’s Landlord and Tenant Act and related statutes.

FAQ: Tenant-Landlord Dispute Resolution in Pennsylvania

1. Who can use Pennsylvania's tenant-landlord mediation programs?
   Most renters and landlords can use mediation services in cities like Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, regardless of the dispute type. Always contact your local agency to check eligibility.
2. Is arbitration in Pennsylvania binding on both renters and landlords?
   Some arbitration programs offer non-binding results (suggestions), while others, such as court-referred arbitrations, can issue decisions enforceable by law. Always confirm the program rules first.
3. What should I bring to a mediation or arbitration session?
   Bring your lease, communication records, receipts, photos of property conditions (if relevant), and any formal notices received from your landlord.
4. Do I need a lawyer to participate in mediation?
   No, most mediation programs do not require a lawyer. However, you may bring one or ask for free legal advice from local resources.
5. How quickly can mediation or arbitration resolve a dispute?
   Many cases settle in days or weeks, much faster than court. Some programs offer same-week appointments for urgent eviction matters.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Find Your Magisterial District Court – The entry point for formal dispute resolution in Pennsylvania.
• Philadelphia Eviction Diversion Program – Free mediation and housing counselor support.
• Pittsburgh Housing Mediation – Help for city renters facing housing disputes.
• Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency (PHFA) – Tenant resources and contacts statewide.
• PA Law Help: Housing – Free legal aid finder for renters.

---

1. Pennsylvania Landlord and Tenant Act of 1951, 68 P.S. §250.101 et seq.
2. Magisterial District Courts (PA Courts official)
3. Philadelphia Eviction Diversion Program
4. Pittsburgh Commission on Human Relations Mediation

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations