Ohio Tenant Rights on Sub-Metering vs. Master Meter Utilities

Many Ohio renters are unsure how utility charges are calculated and what rights they have when living in apartments with sub-metering or master metering systems. Knowing your rights when it comes to utility billing can help you avoid surprises and resolve disputes with your landlord. This article guides Ohio tenants through key differences, billing requirements, and how to seek help if utilities become a problem.

Understanding Sub-Metering and Master Meter Billing

Ohio landlords may use different methods to determine your share of utility costs. It's important to know what system your building uses.

Sub-Metering

• What it is: Sub-meters track each unit's actual usage for utilities like water or electricity.
• Billing: You pay only for what you consume, based on your sub-meter readings.
• Regulation: Non-utility third-party billing for sub-metered systems is permitted in Ohio, but must follow clear rules for transparency.^[1]

Master Meter Billing

• What it is: One "master meter" tracks all tenants' combined usage. The landlord receives the bill and divides it among units, often based on apartment size, number of occupants, or square footage.
• Billing: You pay a calculated share, which may not match your personal usage.
• Possible Issues: Disputes sometimes arise around fairness, especially if units vary widely in occupancy or efficiency.

Ohio Tenant Rights for Utility Billing

The Ohio Revised Code Chapter 5321 (Landlord-Tenant Law) sets out basic requirements for utility billing and landlord responsibilities.

• Written Lease Disclosure: Ohio law requires that if utilities are not included in the rent, your lease must clearly state who is responsible for which utilities.^[2]
• For sub-metering, landlords must provide detailed bills and explain how charges are calculated.^[3]
• If you are being billed by a third party, you are entitled to an itemized statement showing your usage and costs.
• For master-metered buildings, the division of costs must be clearly described in your rental agreement.
• No "extra" fees can be added except those specified in your written lease.
• Utility shutoffs by a landlord (without a proper legal basis) are not allowed. If you face a shutoff, you may contact the local municipal court or the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO).

Official Forms and How to File a Dispute

If you believe you are being overcharged or unfairly billed, you have options. Here are steps and forms that might be helpful:

1. Requesting a Lease Review or Complaint

• Form: Complaint for Tenant's Enforcement of Rental Agreement (No standard state-wide form, but your local municipal court may provide a version)
• Use: If your landlord does not follow proper billing practices, you can use this complaint form to request a hearing with the court.
• Where to File: Take the completed form to your local Ohio Municipal Court.

2. Utility Bill Dispute with a Third Party

• Form: Dispute Resolution Request (no mandatory form; contact PUCO Complaint Portal to file online)
• Use: If you are disputing a bill serviced by a utility company regulated by PUCO (for example, electricity or natural gas), file a complaint directly with PUCO.

Relevant Tribunal and Statutes in Ohio

• Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) – Handles utility disputes and service complaints.
• Ohio Revised Code Chapter 5321 (Landlord-Tenant Law)

FAQ: Renters' Common Questions About Utilities

1. Can my landlord charge me extra fees for utilities in Ohio?
   Only the charges specifically listed in your lease or required by the utility company can be collected. Ask for an itemized bill if fees seem unclear.
2. What should I do if I never received a utility bill or explanation?
   You have the right to a clear explanation of any charges. Send your landlord a written request for a statement, and contact PUCO or your court if no response is received.
3. Who handles utility shutoff disputes in Ohio?
   If a regulated utility threatens shutoff, contact PUCO. If your landlord is shutting off utilities, you may file a complaint in your local municipal court.
4. Do master-metered utility arrangements have to be disclosed?
   Yes, your lease must specify how utility costs are calculated and allocated among tenants.
5. What official resources can help with unresolved billing problems?
   Contact the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio or your local legal aid office for free guidance and complaint resolution.

Key Takeaways for Ohio Renters

• Ohio law protects your right to clear, accurate utility billing, whether you live in a sub-metered or master-metered unit.
• Your lease must detail who pays for which utilities, and any extra fees must be disclosed in writing.
• If you have a billing dispute, you can seek help from PUCO, your local municipal court, or legal aid organizations.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO): Utility complaints, consumer protection info, and dispute filing.
• Ohio Municipal Courts Directory: Find your local court for rental disputes.
• Ohio Legal Help: Guidance, forms, and legal aid contacts for renters.
• Ohio Attorney General: Consumer protection complaints and inquiry options.

---

1. Ohio Revised Code §5321.04 – Landlord Obligations
2. Ohio Revised Code §5321.18 – Written Rental Agreements
3. PUCO: Submetering Billing Policy

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations