Disputing Your Water Bill as a Renter in North Carolina

If you’re renting in North Carolina and receive a water bill that seems incorrect or unfair, you have specific rights and pathways to dispute it. North Carolina law requires clear communication between landlords and tenants regarding utilities and outlines steps renters can take to resolve water bill disagreements. Knowing these steps can help ensure you aren’t overcharged and that disputes are handled fairly.

Water Billing in North Carolina Rentals: Your Rights and Responsibilities

Water bills can be handled differently depending on your lease. In some properties, landlords include water in rent, while in others, renters pay based on usage through submetering or allocated billing. State law, through NC General Statute § 42-42.1, requires landlords to provide:

• A clear description of how water charges are calculated
• Written notice of any changes to water billing methods or rates
• Detailed bills showing usage and charges

Understanding what your lease says about utilities is the first step to resolving any water bill dispute.

Common Reasons for Water Bill Disputes

• Suspected leaks or faulty meters
• Unexpected increase in usage or charges
• Bills not matching what your lease describes
• Charges for water you didn’t use

Renters have the right to request documentation and clarification about any charges that seem incorrect.

How to Dispute a Water Bill in North Carolina

If you believe your water bill is incorrect, follow these steps to address the issue:

• Check your lease and billing details: Review your lease for utility clauses. Compare the billed usage and rates against your rental agreement and previous bills.
• Request clarification in writing: Contact your landlord or property manager in writing, asking for an explanation and supporting documents (such as meter readings or rate calculations). Retain copies for your records.
• Inspect for leaks or meter issues: Ask for an inspection of your unit and the meter. Leaks or faulty meters are common causes of high bills.
• File a formal complaint: If you can't resolve the dispute with your landlord, you can submit a written complaint to the North Carolina Utilities Commission if your landlord bills you through submeters or allocates utility costs.

Relevant Official Forms and How to Use Them

• NC Utilities Commission Formal Complaint Form (Form CE-1)
  When to use: If your landlord is providing water utility services under submetering or allocates water costs per apartment, and you disagree with charges, use this form to start a formal complaint process.
  How to file: Complete the NC Utilities Commission Consumer Complaint Form online or download, fill out, and mail Fax/email the completed form as instructed on the site.

Filing a formal complaint is appropriate if your landlord fails to correct billing errors, refuses documentation, or you suspect ongoing unfair billing.

Who Handles Tenant Utility Complaints in North Carolina?

The North Carolina Utilities Commission resolves disputes where landlords provide water/sewer services and charge tenants directly. General rental disputes (like non-payment or eviction due to bills) may also fall under the jurisdiction of your local District Court.

Understanding North Carolina’s Tenant Legislation

Tenant rights and responsibilities for utilities are primarily covered by North Carolina General Statutes Chapter 42 Article 5, including how and when landlords can bill tenants separately for water and what notice they must provide.

FAQ: Renters’ Water Bill Dispute Questions

1. What if my landlord charges more than what the local utility charges for water?
   North Carolina law limits landlords to charging no more than the amount billed by the water utility, plus an administrative fee set by the Utilities Commission ¹.
2. Can my landlord shut off my water if I dispute a bill?
   No, landlords cannot legally disconnect water service due to a billing dispute. Utility shut-off for nonpayment is regulated and subject to due process.
3. Am I responsible for leaks in my apartment?
   Landlords are required to provide a habitable residence, which includes repairing leaks. However, if you cause damage or delay reporting, you could be responsible for costs ¹.
4. Where do I file a complaint about overbilling or inadequate response?
   Submit a complaint to the NC Utilities Commission if your charges come through landlord-billed submetering or allocation systems.
5. What records should I keep when disputing my bill?
   Save copies of all bills, written communications, inspection results, and any forms or complaints filed.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways for NC Renters

• Carefully check your lease and all water bills for accuracy and keep good records of communications.
• You have the right to clarification and documentation about any water charges.
• If informal resolution fails, use the NC Utilities Commission’s complaint process for a formal review.

By following these steps and understanding your legal rights, you can resolve most water bill disputes confidently and fairly.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• North Carolina Utilities Commission Consumer Complaint Form – For water/sewer billing complaints from landlord-managed properties
• North Carolina Utilities Commission – Main government agency for utility disputes
• North Carolina Judicial Branch: Landlord-Tenant – General information on renter rights and court processes
• North Carolina General Statutes Chapter 42 – Complete landlord-tenant law for North Carolina
• Legal Aid of North Carolina – Free legal help for eligible renters facing unresolved disputes

---

1. NC General Statute § 42-42.1: Rental property water billing
2. NC Utilities Commission: File a Utility Complaint
3. North Carolina General Statutes Chapter 42

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations