What to Do If Your Landlord Breaks the Lease in New York

If you're renting in New York and your landlord breaks your lease—by evicting you early, failing to provide agreed services, or unilaterally ending the tenancy—it's essential to know your rights and the next legal steps. New York law offers renters specific protections, and several official avenues exist for seeking help or compensation. This guide explains what to do and where to get official support.

Recognizing a Landlord Breach in New York

Under the New York Real Property Law, a landlord breaking a lease may include:

• Evicting you without proper legal process
• Changing locks or removing your belongings
• Significantly increasing rent in violation of your lease contract
• Stopping essential services (like heat, water, or repairs) promised in your lease
• Trying to end your tenancy before the lease term without valid reasons

If any of these apply, it's considered a "breach of lease." As a renter, you have the right to address this under state law.

What Steps Should You Take?

Follow these key steps to protect yourself and resolve the situation:

• Review Your Lease: Carefully check your lease contract for terms about early termination or landlord responsibilities.
• Document Everything: Keep records of communication, notices, and any changes in your living conditions.
• Request Written Explanation: Ask your landlord to explain in writing why they are breaking the lease.
• Know Your Rights: New York law requires landlords to provide written notice and, in most cases, cannot end a lease early without cause. See details in NY State Courts Tenant Rights.
• File an Official Complaint if Needed: If your landlord won't resolve the issue, you may take formal action (see below).

Official Forms for New York Renters

In certain cases, you may need to use an official form to take legal action or defend your rights:

• Order to Show Cause (Nonpayment or Holdover):
  Form: "Order to Show Cause" (no specific state-wide number; varies by court)
  Use: If your landlord has broken the lease and started an eviction, you can ask the Housing Court to pause or stop the eviction until the issue is reviewed.
  Example: If your landlord tries to force you out without notice, file an Order to Show Cause to have a judge hear your side.
  Official source: NYC Housing Court Forms (see "Order to Show Cause" instructions)
• Tenant’s Answer to a Petition:
  Form: "Tenant's Answer"
  Use: When a landlord files a petition to remove you or terminate the lease, use this to formally respond.
  Example: If your landlord claims you violated the lease but you believe they broke the lease first, use this form to explain your defense.
  Official source: Tenant's Answer PDF

Where to File and Seek Help

In New York, the tribunal that handles residential tenancy disputes is the New York City Housing Court (for NYC) or your local Civil or District Court (for other counties). Visit their websites for more county-specific forms and procedures. The courts oversee disputes involving breach of lease, evictions, and landlord-tenant rights.

How to File a Complaint or Legal Action

Filing a complaint or action in New York follows these main steps:

• Gather evidence (lease, communications, photos, etc.)
• Complete the "Order to Show Cause" or other relevant court form
• File the papers at your local Housing Court (or use their e-filing where available)
• Attend your hearing—bring all documentation and be ready to explain the landlord's breach
• Court staff can explain the process, but they cannot give legal advice

If the court rules in your favor, you may be allowed to stay, be awarded damages, or have your lease restored.

FAQ: Renter Rights in New York When a Landlord Breaks the Lease

1. Can my landlord evict me before my lease ends?
   In most cases, no. Your landlord must have a legal reason, give proper notice, and obtain a court order. Self-help eviction is illegal in New York.
2. What if my landlord stops making repairs?
   You can file a complaint with your local housing agency or request repairs through the Housing Court. Document all requests and, if unresolved, seek a court order for repairs.
3. Will I still owe rent if my landlord breaks the lease?
   You must keep paying rent unless a court rules otherwise, but you may be entitled to compensation or to end your own obligations if the landlord’s breach is severe.
4. How do I get my security deposit back if the lease is broken?
   New York law requires the landlord to return the deposit (minus legal deductions) within 14 days after you move out. You may sue in Small Claims Court if it’s withheld unfairly.
5. Where can I get free legal help?
   Many New York non-profits and the courts offer free legal clinics or advice for tenants facing a landlord’s breach. See the resources section below for contacts.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• NYC Housing Court: Handles residential disputes in New York City
• NYS Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) – Renter Resources
• NY Attorney General – Tenant Rights
• NY State Courts: Housing Issues Help Center
• Free legal services:
  • Legal Services Corporation – Find Legal Aid in New York
  • LawHelp NY

---

1. New York State Real Property Law (RPP), available at NY Real Property Law – Full Text
2. New York City Housing Court, official forms and guide: NYC Housing Court Forms
3. Tenant Rights Overview: NYS Attorney General: Tenant Rights
4. NYC Department of Housing Preservation & Development: Renter Rights Page

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations