Resolving Water Bill Disputes as a Tenant in Montana

Many renters in Montana find themselves facing questions about water bills—who should pay, what counts as a fair charge, and what to do if a dispute arises with your landlord or property manager. Understanding your rights under Montana law can help you address any water billing issues confidently and fairly.

Understanding Your Water Bill Responsibilities in Montana

Water utility charges in Montana rental housing are governed by your lease agreement and the Montana Residential Landlord and Tenant Act. Most often, lease agreements clearly state whether the landlord or tenant is responsible for water bills. Make sure to:

• Review your written lease for a utilities section
• Check if water costs are included in rent or billed separately
• Ask for clarification from your landlord if the responsibility is unclear

If your lease does not specify who pays for water, Montana law may consider it the landlord's responsibility, but this can depend on local custom and property type.^[1]

Common Water Bill Disputes and What You Can Do

Water bill disputes often arise due to:

• Unexpectedly high bills
• Unclear or missing meters
• Being charged for water usage by other tenants
• Incorrect calculations or billing errors

If you believe your water bill is inaccurate or unfair, you have several options as a tenant.

Step-by-Step: How to Dispute a Water Bill

• Check your lease agreement for utility terms and what it says about water charges.
• Request a copy of recent billing statements or meter readings from your landlord.
• Contact your local water utility to clarify charges if you are billed directly.
• If billed by the landlord, ask for written documentation of how the charges are calculated.
• If a mistake persists, send a written notice to your landlord identifying the problem and requesting correction. Keep a copy for your records.

Using Official Forms to Address Water Bill Issues

• Notice of Dispute (Written Notice): While Montana does not have a standardized government form for water billing disputes, tenants should submit a clear, dated written notice to the landlord outlining the water bill issue and proposed solution. This written notice is recommended before escalating further.
  Example: You receive a water bill for $200, which seems much higher than usual. You write your landlord a formal letter explaining your concerns and ask for documentation or a corrected bill.
• Mediation or Complaint: If a dispute cannot be resolved through discussion, you may request mediation or file a complaint with the Montana Department of Labor & Industry – Board of Housing. There is no specific form for water bill complaints, but written communication is required for your case to be considered.
  Example: After repeated attempts to resolve the problem, you provide copies of your lease, bills, and correspondence when submitting your complaint.

Key Tip: Always communicate in writing and keep copies of all correspondence, bills, and relevant documents. If you pay an incorrect bill under protest, clearly state "paid under protest" in your payment notes or communications.

Rights and Protections Under Montana Law

Tenants in Montana are protected by the Montana Residential Landlord and Tenant Act of 1977, which governs lease terms, landlord responsibilities, and processes for dispute resolution.^[2] The Act requires clarity about who pays for utilities and provides a process for resolving disputes. It also prohibits landlords from shutting off utilities to force payment, which is considered a "constructive eviction."

What if My Water Bill Is Unusually High?

Large or irregular bills may be caused by leaks, shared meters, or calculation mistakes. Under Montana law, tenants should not be charged for water they did not use or for leaks not caused by them. Promptly communicate any issues to your landlord, and document when and to whom you reported the problem.

How to File a Water Bill Dispute Complaint in Montana

If communication doesn't resolve your dispute, you can:

• Contact the Montana Board of Housing, the official agency handling landlord-tenant matters.
• Submit a written complaint with supporting evidence.
• Request mediation services (as available) within your city or county.

In some cases, renters may take small claims action for overpayments or damages related to wrongful billing. Always confirm procedures and eligibility by contacting the agency or your local courthouse directly.

Frequently Asked Water Bill Dispute Questions

1. Can my landlord charge me for water if it's not listed in my lease?
   Generally, if your lease does not specify you are responsible for water, Montana law may view water as the landlord's responsibility.^[3]
2. What can I do if my landlord won't correct a billing mistake?
   If written requests fail, you can involve the Montana Board of Housing or pursue small claims action as a next step.
3. Is my landlord allowed to shut off water due to a rent or utility dispute?
   No, landlords cannot legally shut off any essential service, including water, as a form of retaliation or to "force" payment.^[2]
4. Do I pay for water lost due to leaking pipes in the apartment?
   Unless the leak was your fault, tenants typically are not responsible for excess water charges due to property maintenance issues.
5. How can I get help understanding my water bill?
   You can request a detailed bill from your landlord or ask your local water utility for a usage breakdown.

Conclusion: What Montana Renters Should Remember

• Check your lease for water payment terms and clarify anything unclear in writing.
• Use written communication to resolve water bill disputes and keep all documents.
• Contact Montana Board of Housing if your landlord will not correct errors or if essential services are threatened.

By taking these steps, you can protect your rights and more quickly resolve water bill disputes as a renter in Montana.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Montana Board of Housing – For formal landlord-tenant complaints and dispute resolution
• Montana Housing Division – General tenant resources, eligibility for assistance
• Montana Residential Landlord and Tenant Act of 1977 – Full legislation text
• Montana Legal Services Association – Free or low-cost legal assistance for qualifying tenants

---

1. Montana Residential Landlord and Tenant Act, § 70-24-201
2. Tenant Rights and Duties Under the Montana Residential Landlord and Tenant Act, § 70-24-303
3. Utility Responsibility and Rent Agreements, § 70-24-202

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations