Refusing to Move In After a Rental Inspection in Massachusetts

Renting in Massachusetts comes with important protections for tenants during the move-in process. Before officially taking possession, you're entitled to inspect the property and check its condition. But what happens if the inspection reveals problems? Can you refuse to move in? Let’s break down your rights and the steps involved, focusing on Massachusetts law.

Understanding Move-In Inspections and Your Rights

Massachusetts law gives renters important safeguards when it comes to rental inspections and disclosures. Before your lease starts, landlords must provide a written statement of the apartment’s current condition, called a "statement of condition." This document is crucial if you find damage or code violations during your move-in inspection.

When Can a Renter Legally Refuse to Move In?

You have the right to refuse moving in if, during your inspection, you find:

• Major repairs or health and safety violations not disclosed earlier (like mold, pests, broken heaters, or no running water)
• Conditions that make the unit uninhabitable according to the Massachusetts State Sanitary Code
• Substantial differences between what was promised in your lease and the actual unit (e.g., the wrong apartment or missing promised amenities)

If any of these issues are present and not corrected, you may lawfully walk away without penalty and request the return of your security deposit and any prepaid rent.

The Importance of the Statement of Condition Form

Form name: Statement of Condition
How it's used: You receive this form when the landlord collects a security deposit. Review it carefully. Note any problems not listed and return a signed copy to your landlord within 15 days.
Official source: Massachusetts Sample Statement of Condition (PDF)

Practical example: Imagine moving in and discovering water damage that isn’t listed on the provided form. Note this and any other issues on the Statement of Condition, then submit it to your landlord within 15 days. This protects your security deposit and documents problems you didn’t cause.

What Massachusetts Law Says

The Massachusetts State Sanitary Code (105 CMR 410) outlines minimum standards for rental housing. If violations make your unit unfit for living, you can refuse occupancy.

Additionally, under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 186, Section 15B, tenants may refuse to accept an apartment that's uninhabitable at move-in or not as promised in the lease.

What to Do If You Discover Problems During Inspection

If you find issues during your move-in walkthrough, take these steps:

• Take photos or video of the damaged or hazardous areas
• Note every issue on the Statement of Condition form
• Submit the completed form to your landlord within 15 days and keep a copy
• Request that repairs be made before moving in or negotiate any needed changes to the lease
• If the problems are serious and not resolved, notify the landlord in writing that you are refusing to move in due to habitability issues

Returning Your Security Deposit and Rent

If you lawfully refuse to move in, your landlord must return your security deposit and any prepaid rent. If they do not, you can file a complaint with the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office or pursue your deposit in Small Claims Court.

Tribunals and Who to Contact

The Massachusetts Housing Court handles disputes related to rental housing, including move-in condition disputes and deposit issues.

FAQ: Common Questions About Move-In Inspections and Refusing Occupancy

1. Can I back out of a lease after finding serious issues at move-in?
   Yes. If major health or safety violations exist and are not fixed before your move-in date, you can refuse to move in and cancel the lease without penalty.
2. What is considered "uninhabitable" in Massachusetts?
   An apartment is uninhabitable if it violates the State Sanitary Code, such as lacking heat, water, or being infested with pests.
3. Do I get my security deposit back if I don’t move in?
   Yes, as long as you never took possession and the refusal was due to violations or failure to provide agreed conditions.
4. Who can inspect my apartment if I suspect code violations?
   You can request an inspection from your local Board of Health to document any violations officially.
5. Is there a timeline to submit the Statement of Condition?
   Yes, you must return it to your landlord within 15 days of receiving it, signed and with any additions.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways for Massachusetts Renters

• Inspect your new rental carefully and document any problems on the Statement of Condition.
• You can legally refuse to move in if serious, unresolved issues make the unit uninhabitable or it doesn’t match your lease.
• If you don’t move in for these reasons, you have the right to a full refund of your deposit and rent.

Understanding your rights and next steps can help protect your finances and your safety if problems arise at move-in.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Massachusetts Housing Court: For legal disputes or hearings about deposits and tenancy issues
• Office of the Attorney General, Consumer Advocacy & Response Division: For consumer complaints and legal help
• Mass.gov Tenant and Landlord Law Guide: Official guidance and legal forms
• MassLegalHelp: Tenant rights advocacy and plain-language resources
• Your local Board of Health: For free apartment inspections and code enforcement

---

1. Statement of Condition Official Form – Mass.gov
2. Massachusetts State Sanitary Code – 105 CMR 410
3. Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 186, Section 15B

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations