Tenant Options for Disputing Water Bills in California

Unexpected or disputed water bills can be a serious stress for renters in California. Understanding your rights, knowing how charges must be disclosed, and learning what official steps you can take can help you resolve these issues fairly.

When Tenants Pay for Water in California

In California, whether you pay for water depends on your lease agreement. Some leases include water in the rent, while others hold tenants responsible for their own utility bills. State law also requires the landlord to provide certain disclosures if you, the tenant, are required to pay for water through a submeter or allocation system¹. These disclosures must be in writing as part of your rental contract.

• If the water bill is in your name: You pay the utility company directly.
• If billed by the landlord (submetering or allocation): The landlord must provide you with a copy of the bill and a clear calculation method.

Common Water Bill Dispute Scenarios

Water bill conflicts can arise when:

• The bill is much higher than usual without explanation
• Charges seem inaccurate or unrelated to your actual use
• The landlord adds extra fees or charges not listed in your lease
• You never received a required disclosure about water charges in your rental agreement

If you face any of these situations, California law protects your right to question and challenge the charge before making payment.¹

Your Rights Under California Law

California’s tenant protections for utility billing are covered by the California Civil Code Section 1954.201 for water submeters and general rental laws. Landlords cannot demand unexplained or excessive utility fees, and deductions from your security deposit for disputed utilities must follow a legal process.²

If your lease requires you to pay water based on submetering, the landlord must:

• Disclose all charges, fees, and how they are calculated
• Provide copies of each water bill
• Bill only for the period you lived there
• Maintain records for at least 12 months

How to Dispute a Water Bill

To resolve a dispute, follow these steps:

• Ask your landlord for a written explanation and proof of the bill
• Review your lease and California’s utility billing laws
• Contact the water utility (if the bill is in your name) to check for leaks, errors, or account issues
• If the issue is not resolved, you may file a complaint or take your case to small claims court or the appropriate dispute board

Official Forms and Where to Get Help

If discussions with your landlord do not work, you can escalate the complaint:

• Complaint to Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA): If you believe your rights have been violated, you can use the Consumer Complaint Form to file a report with the California Department of Consumer Affairs (Form: Consumer Complaint Form). For example, use this form if you’ve received unexplained water charges and your landlord has refused written evidence or negotiation.
• Small Claims Court: If you seek reimbursement or need to dispute excessive charges, file with your county’s Small Claims division. The official guide is available at the California Courts Self-Help Small Claims site. There is no specific "water bill" form, but you would use the Plaintiff’s Claim and ORDER to Go to Small Claims Court (Form SC-100) to start your case. For example, if your landlord withheld part of your deposit for a disputed water bill, this is the proper form to use.

The official agency for most landlord-tenant disputes in California is the California Department of Consumer Affairs.

Tribunal and Legislation References

• Dispute board/tribunal: For most residential tenancy matters, see the California Department of Consumer Affairs – Landlord/Tenant Section.
• Relevant Legislation: California Civil Code Section 1954.201 – Tenant Protections for Water Submeters; California Civil Code

FAQ: Water Bill Disputes for California Renters

1. Can my landlord charge extra fees for handling water payments?
   Only the specific administrative fee disclosed in your lease and allowed by California law can be added; hidden or surprise fees are not permitted.¹
2. What if the water bill covers more than my rental period?
   You can ask for the charge to be prorated and, if it’s not resolved, file a complaint or bring a claim in small claims court.
3. I never got a copy of a submetered water bill. What are my rights?
   Your landlord is required by law to provide you with the water bill and a clear explanation if you pay for water by submeter. Failure to do so may allow you to dispute the charge and file a complaint.
4. Can the landlord deduct a disputed water bill from my security deposit?
   The landlord can only deduct charges supported by evidence and following proper legal process. Disputes often go to small claims court for resolution.
5. Who do I contact if I need help with a water bill dispute?
   Start with the California Department of Consumer Affairs (Tenant Resources) and consider local legal aid for additional support.

Key Takeaways for California Renters

• Landlords must fully disclose water charges if tenants are responsible for the bill
• If you believe a water bill is inaccurate, request evidence and use formal complaint processes if necessary
• Use California DCA or Small Claims Court if informal resolution fails

By understanding these protections, you can approach water bill disputes with confidence and get fair results.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• California Department of Consumer Affairs – Tenant Resources
• California Courts – Filing a Small Claims Case
• California Legal Aid and Services Directory
• California Civil Code Section 1954.201 – Water Submetering Law

---

1. 1. See California Civil Code Section 1954.201 – Tenant Protections.
2. 2. See California Department of Consumer Affairs – Landlord/Tenant Information.

Categories

Renter Rights & Legal Protections Lease Agreements & Renewals Rent, Fees & Security Deposits Moving In: Inspections & Disclosures Moving Out & Ending a Lease Maintenance, Repairs & Habitability Health & Safety Standards Evictions & Lease Violations Roommates, Subletting & Shared Housing Discrimination & Fair Housing Laws Accessibility & Disability Accommodations Utilities, Services & Billing Affordable Housing & Rental Assistance Rent Control & Rent Stabilization Privacy Rights & Landlord Entry Security, Locks & Emergency Protections Dispute Resolution & Legal Aid Retaliation & Harassment Protections Mobile Home & Manufactured Housing Rights Special Housing Types & Situations